OFFER1 logoOFFER1®
All StoriesCase Study

Monarch Beach Model-Match, Dana Point, CA

Two identical model-match homes across the street, listed weeks apart. The OFFER1 listing sold for $445,000 more.

+$445K
Outperformed neighbor
6
Competing offers
6 days
On market

The Challenge

  • Identical model-match home across the street had just listed using a traditional offer process.
  • Property B had a smaller lot and no ocean view — Property A had both.
  • Buyers in this price tier expect a polished, professional experience.
  • Conventional wisdom said showing the highest offer would depress the final price.

The Strategy

  • Invest $6,000 up front in paint, staging, and outdoor presentation before going live.
  • Concentrate showings into 3 open houses on Saturday, Sunday, and Monday.
  • Run every offer through OFFER1 with a synchronized auction-style countdown.
  • Once 3 offers were in, publish the current highest bid so all buyers competed on visible, equal footing.

The Results

  • Property B closed at $2,225,000 vs. Property A at $1,780,000 — a $445,000 delta on the same model.
  • 6 offers received with full transparency on bidding terms and timing.
  • Closed in the same 6-day market window as the neighbor.
  • Outperformed despite a smaller lot, no ocean view, and a financed (not cash) buyer.

In their own words

"Other buyers' willingness to pay provides a data point and confidence that this property is desirable. It is an instinct to compete — but only when you can see the competition."
— Listing Agent, Monarch Beach
"Olympic 100-yard dashes aren't run in a vacuum. All participants run at the same time and can see who's currently in the lead."
— Listing Agent, Monarch Beach
"A consistent, fair process and an open competitive environment led buyers to compete for the home and reveal its true market value."
— Listing Agent, Monarch Beach

The numbers

Property A sale price
$1,780,000
Property B sale price (OFFER1)
$2,225,000
Delta
+$445,000
Property B offers
6
Property B days on market
6
Pre-list investment
$6,000
Property B lot size
7,208 sqft
Property A lot size
8,364 sqft
Property B view
Park only
"Two identical homes, the same week, on the same street — one sold for $445,000 more. The difference wasn't the property. It was the process."
— Listing Agent, Monarch Beach
Presented by OFFER1 Partner Agent, Listing Agent, Orange County Coast
The Next Generation

Real estate negotiation,
finally reimagined.

Join the listing agents, sellers, and buyers replacing PDFs, emails, and spreadsheets with one beautifully organized platform.

Schedule a demoLog in or sign up